Nearly Three Borrowers in Four Refinance Somewhere Else
You sat with them through the most nerve-racking financial hour of their life. You got it closed. Then the file went quiet, and the next time they needed a mortgage, they called somebody else.
That is not a hunch. It gets measured every quarter.
The number
ICE tracks how many borrowers stay with their mortgage servicer when they refinance. Its November 2026 Mortgage Monitor put the figure at 27% for the third quarter, down four points from the second and the lowest since the third quarter of 2025. Banks kept 10% of their refinancing borrowers, a two-year low. Non-bank servicers kept 35%. For context, the August 2026 Mortgage Monitor had the second quarter at 31%, with banks at 14% and non-banks at 37%.
Turn that around. Nearly three refinancing borrowers in four went to a different lender, and at the banks it was nine in ten. ICE measures the company servicing the loan, not the loan officer who wrote it, so read it as how often borrowers come back to where they were, not as a verdict on you.
ICE also said where the losses came from. Cash-out refinances, borrowers tapping their equity rather than chasing a lower rate, accounted for 75% of the refinance loans servicers lost. ICE's own mortgage technology president put it plainly: rate-based retention strategies "aren't effective" for borrowers who want the equity, not the savings. A rate alert does not reach that borrower. Being the lender they remember might.
The good quarters do not change the shape of it. In March, ICE reported that servicers had kept one refinancing borrower in three in the fourth quarter of 2025, and called it the strongest overall retention rate since early 2014. The best result in more than a decade still lost two out of three. ICE also revises these figures as later data comes in, so if you quote one, quote the month of the report it came from.
The longer the loan sits, the weaker the pull
ICE's March 2026 Mortgage Monitor looked at retention by how long the loan had been on the books. It tends to peak in the year after the loan closes and then slide. For recent vintages, ICE found a 6% to 24% drop between year one and year five.
And the years between calls keep getting longer. The National Association of Realtors' 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers found that sellers had owned their homes a median of 11 years before selling, an all-time high.
Refinance waves come and go with rates, so the next call might come next spring or a decade from now. Nothing you did at the closing table survives that on its own. Something small every year does.
Advice is what builds the pull
J.D. Power's 2025 U.S. Mortgage Origination Satisfaction Study found that customers of lenders that receive top scores for delivering useful guidance were 2.3 times more likely to say they "definitely will" choose the same lender for future loans.
The advice happens before the closing. The card is what keeps that impression alive afterward, through the years when you have no reason to call and they have no reason to think of you.
Your referral partners are the better list
Realtors, title agents, insurance agents, CPAs, builders and attorneys. That list is short, it is worth more per name than any borrower list you have, and it is the one most often left off the card order.
If you are worried about RESPA, read Thanksgiving Cards and the Regulated Professions, where I went through the statute and the regulation. The short version is that a card is a "thing of value," and the card is still not the problem. An agreement to refer business is, and the regulation says that agreement can be inferred from a practice, pattern or course of conduct, not just from something in writing. A gift that rises and falls with how much business someone sends you is the pattern to avoid. The same card, sent to every partner alike, asking for nothing, is about as far from that as a card gets. If you are unsure, ask your compliance person before you mail.
The same goes for borrowers. Put nothing in the card about rates. The line about refinancing is the line that turns a greeting into an ad, and ads go in the recycling.
Credit unions have a different advantage
J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Credit Union Satisfaction Study found that 71% of members say they definitely will use their credit union again, down two points from the year before. It also found that more than half of members now keep checking (59%) and savings (56%) accounts at other financial institutions.
Members are loyal and spread out at the same time. A credit union or community bank is selling the one thing a national lender cannot fake, which is that it is from here. Our US Regions Greetings family puts the place on the card. It is a small move, and it is the one a national lender cannot make.
The short version
Nearly three refinancing borrowers in four go somewhere else, and the pull gets weaker every year the loan sits. They go to whoever they remember. Send the card from the loan officer, with the institution's name underneath, to past borrowers and to the people who send you buyers. The designs we pick for lenders are on our page for mortgage brokers, banks and credit unions.
Ready to send some?
Every design in our catalog is imprintable with your own message, and envelopes are included.
